| 1 | Ken Griffey Jr. Seattle | Seattle Mariners | |
| 2 | Matt Holliday St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 3 | Babe Ruth New York | New York Yankees | |
| 4 | Jon Singleton Houston | Houston Astros | RC |
| 5 | Curtis Granderson New York | New York Mets | |
| 6 | Shane Victorino Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 7 | Adrian Gonzalez Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 8 | Stephen Strasburg Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 9 | Hisashi Iwakuma Seattle | Seattle Mariners | |
| 10 | Sergio Romo San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 11 | Max Scherzer Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 12 | Gio Gonzalez Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 13 | Stan Musial St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 14 | Travis d'Arnaud New York | New York Mets | RC |
| 15 | Mark Trumbo Arizona | Arizona Diamondbacks | |
| 16 | Nolan Arenado Colorado | Colorado Rockies | |
| 17 | Michael Cuddyer Colorado | Colorado Rockies | |
| 18 | Derek Jeter New York | New York Yankees | |
| 19 | Jered Weaver | Los Angeles Angels | |
| 20 | Ivan Rodriguez Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 21 | Roy Halladay Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 22 | Matt Adams St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 23 | John Smoltz Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 24 | Anthony Rizzo Chicago | Chicago Cubs | |
| 25 | Edwin Encarnacion Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 26 | Elvis Andrus Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 27 | Lou Gehrig New York | New York Yankees | |
| 28 | Giancarlo Stanton Miami | Miami Marlins | |
| 29 | Jose Reyes Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 30 | Andrew McCutchen Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 31 | Todd Helton Colorado | Colorado Rockies | |
| 32 | Ernie Banks Chicago | Chicago Cubs | |
| 33 | Tony Cingrani Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 34 | Jordan Zimmermann Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 35 | Brian Dozier Minnesota | Minnesota Twins | |
| 36 | Randy Johnson Arizona | Arizona Diamondbacks | |
| 37 | Hunter Pence San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 38 | Robinson Cano Seattle | Seattle Mariners | |
| 39 | Chase Utley Philadelphia | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 40 | Justin Verlander Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 41 | Shin-Soo Choo Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 42 | Jackie Robinson Brooklyn | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 43 | Pedro Martinez Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 44 | Hank Aaron Milwaukee | Atlanta Braves | |
| 45 | Gregory Polanco Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh Pirates | RC |
| 46 | Rickey Henderson Oakland | Oakland Athletics | |
| 47 | Oscar Taveras St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | RC |
| 48 | Jacoby Ellsbury New York | New York Yankees | |
| 49 | Michael Choice Texas | Texas Rangers | RC |
| 50 | Mike Trout | Los Angeles Angels | |
| 51 | Chris Davis Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 52 | Manny Machado Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 53 | Willie Mays San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 54 | Wil Myers Tampa Bay | Tampa Bay Rays | |
| 55 | Andrew Heaney Miami | Miami Marlins | RC |
| 56 | Nick Castellanos Detroit | Detroit Tigers | RC |
| 57 | Jayson Werth Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 58 | Zack Wheeler New York | New York Mets | |
| 59 | Jonathan Schoop Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | RC |
| 60 | Albert Pujols | Los Angeles Angels | |
| 61 | Alex Guerrero Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | RC |
| 62 | Starling Marte Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 63 | Billy Butler Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | |
| 64 | Tim Lincecum San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 65 | Yu Darvish Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 66 | Matt Cain San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 67 | Ozzie Smith St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 68 | Adrian Beltre Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 69 | Freddie Freeman Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 70 | Justin Upton Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 71 | Ian Kinsler Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 72 | Ty Cobb Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 73 | Matt Carpenter St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 74 | Josh Donaldson Oakland | Oakland Athletics | |
| 75 | Pablo Sandoval San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 76 | Taijuan Walker Seattle | Seattle Mariners | RC |
| 77 | Al Kaline Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 78 | Josh Hamilton | Los Angeles Angels | |
| 79 | Brandon Phillips Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 80 | Roger Clemens Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 81 | Anibal Sanchez Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 82 | Evan Longoria Tampa Bay | Tampa Bay Rays | |
| 83 | Brooks Robinson Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 84 | Aroldis Chapman Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 85 | Kolten Wong St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | RC |
| 86 | David Wright New York | New York Mets | |
| 87 | Joey Votto Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 88 | Wilmer Flores New York | New York Mets | RC |
| 89 | Yordano Ventura Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | RC |
| 90 | Jose Altuve Houston | Houston Astros | |
| 91 | Miguel Cabrera Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 92 | CC Sabathia New York | New York Yankees | |
| 93 | Chris Owings Arizona | Arizona Diamondbacks | RC |
| 94 | George Springer Houston | Houston Astros | RC |
| 95 | Mark McGwire Oakland | Oakland Athletics | |
| 96 | Johnny Cueto Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 97 | Yasiel Puig Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 98 | Victor Martinez Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 99 | Trevor Rosenthal St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 100 | Jose Abreu Chicago | Chicago White Sox | RC |
| 101 | Mike Napoli Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 102 | Adam Jones Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 103 | Adam Eaton Chicago | Chicago White Sox | |
| 104 | Nolan Ryan Houston | Houston Astros | |
| 105 | Troy Tulowitzki Colorado | Colorado Rockies | |
| 106 | Eric Hosmer Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | |
| 107 | Zack Greinke Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 108 | Pedro Alvarez Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 109 | Jeff Bagwell Houston | Houston Astros | |
| 110 | Xander Bogaerts Boston | Boston Red Sox | RC |
| 111 | Duke Snider Brooklyn | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 112 | Albert Belle Cleveland | Cleveland Indians | |
| 113 | Johnny Bench Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 114 | Bob Feller Cleveland | Cleveland Indians | |
| 115 | Jason Heyward Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 116 | Andrelton Simmons Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 117 | Don Mattingly New York | New York Yankees | |
| 118 | Alex Gordon Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | |
| 119 | Sonny Gray Oakland | Oakland Athletics | |
| 120 | Jose Bautista Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 121 | Carlos Gonzalez Colorado | Colorado Rockies | |
| 122 | Craig Kimbrel Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 123 | Andre Dawson Chicago | Chicago Cubs | |
| 124 | Billy Hamilton Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | RC |
| 125 | Madison Bumgarner San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 126 | Torii Hunter Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 127 | Roberto Clemente Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 128 | Marcus Stroman Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | RC |
| 129 | Hanley Ramirez Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 130 | Starlin Castro Chicago | Chicago Cubs | |
| 131 | Dustin Pedroia Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 132 | Wilin Rosario Colorado | Colorado Rockies | |
| 133 | Ted Williams Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 134 | Carlos Beltran New York | New York Yankees | |
| 135 | Eddie Butler Colorado | Colorado Rockies | RC |
| 136 | Jason Kipnis Cleveland | Cleveland Indians | |
| 137 | Julio Teheran Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 138 | Wade Boggs Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 139 | Koji Uehara Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 140 | Mookie Betts Boston | Boston Red Sox | RC |
| 141 | Evan Gattis Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 142 | Matt Harvey New York | New York Mets | |
| 143 | Jean Segura Milwaukee | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 144 | Yoenis Cespedes Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 145 | Matt Kemp Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 146 | Jay Bruce Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 147 | Bo Jackson Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | |
| 148 | Salvador Perez Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | |
| 149 | Mike Piazza Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 150 | Clayton Kershaw Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 151 | Sandy Koufax Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 152 | Nelson Cruz Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 153 | Bryce Harper Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 154 | Chris Sale Chicago | Chicago White Sox | |
| 155 | Michael Wacha St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 156 | Prince Fielder Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 157 | Jurickson Profar Texas | Texas Rangers | |
| 158 | Hyun-Jin Ryu Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 159 | Mariano Rivera New York | New York Yankees | |
| 160 | Joe Mauer Minnesota | Minnesota Twins | |
| 161 | Tony Gwynn San Diego | San Diego Padres | |
| 162 | Jose Canseco Oakland | Oakland Athletics | |
| 163 | Masahiro Tanaka New York | New York Yankees | RC |
| 164 | Ryan Braun Milwaukee | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 165 | Cole Hamels Philadelphia | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 166 | Mat Latos Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 167 | Domonic Brown Philadelphia | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 168 | Adam Wainwright St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 169 | Shelby Miller St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 170 | Ryan Howard Philadelphia | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 171 | Robin Yount Milwaukee | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 172 | Arismendy Alcantara Chicago | Chicago Cubs | RC |
| 173 | Mike Schmidt Philadelphia | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 174 | Yadier Molina St. Louis | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 175 | Jose Fernandez Miami | Miami Marlins | |
| 176 | Jeff Samardzija Oakland | Oakland Athletics | |
| 177 | Eddie Murray Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 178 | Greg Maddux Atlanta | Atlanta Braves | |
| 179 | Felix Hernandez Seattle | Seattle Mariners | |
| 180 | Ian Desmond Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 181 | C.J. Cron Angels Rookie | | |
| 182 | David Ortiz Boston | Boston Red Sox | |
| 183 | Carlos Gomez Milwaukee | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 184 | Cliff Lee Philadelphia | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 185 | Buster Posey San Francisco | San Francisco Giants | |
| 186 | Carl Crawford Los Angeles | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 187 | Christian Yelich Miami | Miami Marlins | |
| 188 | George Brett Kansas City | Kansas City Royals | |
| 189 | David Price Detroit | Detroit Tigers | |
| 190 | Todd Frazier Cincinnati | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 191 | Gerrit Cole Pittsburgh | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 192 | Brett Lawrie Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 193 | R.A. Dickey Toronto | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 194 | Tom Seaver New York | New York Mets | |
| 195 | Chris Archer Tampa Bay | Tampa Bay Rays | |
| 196 | Ryan Zimmerman Washington | Washington Nationals | |
| 197 | Cal Ripken Jr. Baltimore | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 198 | Carlos Santana Cleveland | Cleveland Indians | |
| 199 | Paul Goldschmidt Arizona | Arizona Diamondbacks | |
| 200 | Joe DiMaggio New York | New York Yankees | |
